Explained: What Are The Arguments For Same-Sex Marriages In Supreme Court, What All Has Been Said So Far?

Date: May 15, 2023In a landmark case before the Supreme Court, the issue of same-sex marriages has garnered significant attention as the court deliberates on the constitutionality and legal recognition of these unions. The arguments presented thus far by proponents of same-sex marriages have centered around equality, personal freedoms, and the broader societal benefits. Here’s a recap of what has been said in the ongoing Supreme Court proceedings.Source:- NPR
1. Equality and Non-Discrimination:Advocates for same-sex marriages have passionately argued that denying these unions is a form of discrimination based on sexual orientation. They contend that marriage is a fundamental right guaranteed to all individuals, regardless of their sexual orientation, as upheld by the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. By denying same-sex couples the right to marry, proponents argue that the government perpetuates an unequal treatment of LGBTQ+ individuals, which undermines the principles of equal rights and protections.
2. Constitutional Protection of Personal Freedoms:Another key argument put forth in favor of same-sex marriages revolves around the protection of personal freedoms. Proponents argue that individuals have the right to choose their life partners and establish a family, and that this right should not be limited by gender or sexual orientation. They assert that the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment safeguards an individual’s liberty interest in choosing their spouse, and that excluding same-sex couples from marriage infringes upon this constitutionally protected right.
3. Benefits to Society:Advocates for same-sex marriages contend that legalizing these unions benefits both same-sex couples and society as a whole. They argue that granting marriage rights to same-sex couples strengthens family bonds, provides legal protections, and enhances the overall stability and well-being of LGBTQ+ families. Moreover, proponents highlight that legal recognition of same-sex marriages promotes social acceptance, combats stigmatization, and contributes to a more inclusive society.
4. Precedent and Public Opinion:Proponents of same-sex marriages have also emphasized the importance of precedent and evolving public opinion. They point to previous Supreme Court rulings, such as Obergefell v. Hodges in 2015, which established the constitutional right to same-sex marriage. Advocates argue that these precedents should guide the current case, highlighting the need for consistency and the recognition of same-sex marriages as a settled matter of law. Furthermore, they highlight the growing support for same-sex marriages among the general public, citing opinion polls and societal shifts that reflect an increased acceptance and understanding of LGBTQ+ rights.
As the Supreme Court deliberates on this crucial matter, these arguments for same-sex marriages continue to shape the discussions within the legal community and society at large. The court’s ultimate ruling will have far-reaching consequences, potentially solidifying the legal standing and recognition of same-sex marriages in the United States for years to come.
What do you think about this ? Comment below