The National Assessment and Accreditation Council (NAAC) plays a pivotal role in evaluating higher education institutions in India. However, recent controversies have highlighted critical flaws in NAAC’s assessment methodology, offering essential lessons on how not to evaluate universities.
Source:- bbc news
First, transparency issues have emerged. The NAAC’s evaluation process lacks a consistent, transparent framework that universities and stakeholders can rely on. For instance, scoring criteria are not always publicly disclosed, leading to perceptions of subjectivity and bias. This opaqueness hinders the credibility of the evaluations and makes it challenging for institutions to improve based on actionable insights.
Source:- bbc news
Second, there is an over-reliance on quantitative metrics, which doesn’t capture the full essence of a university’s academic and social contributions. Factors such as research output, faculty qualifications, and student outcomes are important, yet they represent only part of an institution’s impact. NAAC often emphasizes numerical data over qualitative insights, sidelining factors like inclusivity, student satisfaction, and community engagement. This narrow focus may encourage universities to prioritize numbers over holistic education quality.
Furthermore, NAAC’s assessment lacks adaptability to diverse institutional contexts. Universities across India vary in size, funding, demographics, and focus areas. A standardized one-size-fits-all approach does not fairly assess specialized or under-resourced institutions. Ignoring these nuances can lead to unfair evaluations, discouraging universities rather than fostering growth.
Finally, instances of alleged corruption within NAAC have surfaced, diminishing trust in its assessments. Claims of bribes or undue influence compromise the objectivity and fairness expected from an accrediting body.
To restore faith, NAAC must overhaul its assessment practices, emphasizing transparency, adaptability, and integrity. By adopting a more holistic approach and adapting to each university’s unique context, NAAC can provide more meaningful and constructive feedback that genuinely promotes quality in higher education across India.
Share your views in the comments
